Sunday, November 18, 2012

The Genesis of Dialogue, Interaction Patterns for Coming Together



 
The most important story to a couple in a romantic relationship is the story of how they met.  It is also the most common question asked of a couple no matter the context; most likely second in line to the question about children.  An exceptional story of a romantic chance encounter can be, and usually does result in tradition of telling, used as a bed time story for their children, grandchildren and great grandchildren.  The text, Interpersonal Communication and Human Relationships by Knapp and Vangelisti, says the most common attraction to a relationship, even subconsciously, is to meet future relationship partners in an atypical, unpredictable manner. By examining selected scenes from the culturally inspiring films Hitch, Fools Rush In, The Notebook, The Break-Up, and Hope Floats I will discuss various atypical, yet motivating, initial interaction. This is a film analysis of the attraction of romantic relationships and how relationship partners get together.

Following the lead of the authors, Mark L. Knapp and Anita L. Vangelisti, my analysis dissects the process of “getting together.” First, there will be an examination of the impulses associated with the process then a discussion on the stages which impulses would most likely occur and the external conditions that may enable or inhibit the initial interaction.  Secondly, there will be a brief discussion on how “sizing up the other person” can happen too late in the bonding stage as seen in the appropriately titled film, Fools Rush In.  That will be followed by an analysis of the relationship between Jennifer Aniston and Vince Vaughn in the 2006 comedy, The Break-Up. This film provides a significant number of examples of how each person’s perception of the relationship differently affects the relationship during the interaction stages from differentiating to avoiding.  Because a relationship could almost be described as an entity in and of it-self I see relationships as living organisms which can be sustained or die and require a conscious mental, emotional and physical effort from each person.  It is also important to point out that our perception of others and the perception of our selves will change over time. The effect of that acknowledgment, as he/she moves through various stages of relationships, will also change over time.  For example, in The Notebook Noah and Allie’s relationship was ruined by obligations to their social classes.  Each of them had to deal with issues of education, war, and death but from their different perspective of reality. Although the two were drastically different they finally came together at the end and moved through the stages of life as one.  Fifthly, the film Hope Floats will be used to illustrate the principles, theories and analyses of the many aspects of attraction to distinctive types of relationships. For me, the Pollyanna Principle was strongly evident in Sandra Bullock’s character, Birdee.  She was raised in a home where the family displayed an attitude as though “pleasant events were more likely to occur than unpleasant.” (Knapp, 1984) 

To properly discuss the process of getting together one must first discuss the reasons people are receptive to begin including another individual. There is no need to pretend relationships are perfect, or will be perfect for matter.  So why do we invite individuals into our life? To begin, the motivating force behind a person commonly going to a bar, trying something new like speed dating or even taking life risking measures like agreeing to a coffee date with a person they met an online, is because the impulse to receive stimulation is in everyone. 

Keep in mind, there are different types of stimulation that a person can want, such as, mental stimulation.  An individual may want to expand their mind and the impulse to receive stimulation may possibly be the same motivating force as in the desire to become a “we” instead of an “I.”  However, it was Knapp and Vangelisti who said the impulse is nothing other than a person physically filling a psychological void.  The person(s) are void of excitement, variety and/or secretly long for a change of pace within their otherwise suitable lifestyle.  An example of this is Kevin James’ character, Albert Brennaman, in the movie Hitch.  Albert was satisfied with his job, had a beautiful New York apartment but he wanted the excitement of dating Allegra Cole. His want motivates him to contact Hitch and finally initiate the romance. Once a relationship has been initiated, depending upon the context of the physical interaction upon initiation (if a couple had sex right away or later), then the impulse to enhance the enjoyment of certain activities should occur immediately, if not simultaneously, with the impulse to receive stimulation. 

The stage of experimenting is often where feelings of trust begin to grow within each person and becomes a physical extension of their love within their reality.  That means that each person physically makes an extra effort to accommodate their partner’s likes and dislikes, such as buying their partner’s favorite cereal just because it will make them happy.  This is also the stage where the impulse to express personal experiences occurs.  Although that phase is not seen, it is implied in the opening credits of The Break-Up where various pictures of Brooke and Gary are displayed insinuating that personal information, such as, likes, dislikes, and childhood stories were most likely exchanged.  In Hitch, Hitch actually does the same thing, but in reverse.  He actually shows Sara (Eva Mendes) something about her own family history, her grandfather’s immigration record when he entered America.

People watching is often claimed to be a favorite pastime for many people, so it is no surprise that as a couple approach the bonding process that mates often require the other to pass a series of “obstacles” to determine eligibility and compatibility.  Actually, “sizing the person up” most commonly originates on day one of the relationship however, there are instances when the couple rush through several stages of the relationship and then allow themselves to accurately view their partner.  For example, in Fools Rush In the characters Alex and Isabel, played by Matthew Perry and Salma Hayek, meet in an atypical manner, spend a night together, and because Isabel is pregnant, get married and then begin sizing each other up. For instance, the scene when Isabel and Alex are in bed engaging in pillow talk is a more intimate portrayal of sizing a person up.  This strategy of sizing up a person initially came from the minds of Miell and Duck. Meill and Duck said couples most commonly ask direct questions, observe the other during the response and then use reciprocal self-disclosure to verbally and non-verbally communicate vulnerability and insecurities.  Also, in Fools Rush In there is a non-intimate example of sizing up a person.  For instance, when Alex’s and Isabel’s parents meet for the first time, Alex (Matthew Perry) can be seen in the background staring directly at Isabel’s father.  Isabel’s father literally stands up to his father, Richard.  Most likely Alex is taking in Isabel’s father’s physical structure and social behavior within the situation.  In my opinion it is never too late to begin sizing up your mate however the relationship may last much longer if a more accurate, realistic view of the partner is established in the beginning. 

Perception is the process of using the senses to obtain information about the surrounding environment, situation[1] or person(s).  Perception is an individualistic understanding based on observations, thoughts and attitudes[2] and is unconsciously triggered by each person’s education, culture and experiences within those contexts.  Each person’s perception is different because what each person observes in a situation is different; the individual’s perception in a relationship differently affects the relationship during the interaction stages of differentiating, circumscribing, stagnating and avoiding.  The romantic comedy, The Break-Up, is the prime example of different perceptions affecting the interaction stages.  The characters Gary and Brooke initiate their engagement in an atypical manner, Gary perceived Brooke was with the wrong guy and initiated communication.  Therefore it would be safe to assume Brooke was mentally and physically stimulated by Gary’s approach because they began a relationship, dating.  Again, the opening credits are an example of the experimenting and intensifying stages, a visual representation of the evolution of Brooke and Gary’s relationship growth and their systematic movement through the interaction stages. Scenes of Brooke and Gary purchasing a condo embody the integrating and bonding stages of a relationship, movement forward.  Then from the argument and relationship dissolution scene, after the dinner party, the remaining portion of the film demonstrates the differentiating, circumscribing, stagnating, avoiding and terminating stages. 

Jennifer Aniston’s character, Brooke, demonstrates a perspective of the relationship dissolution that raises an interesting point. I doubt this is the first time Gary has chosen to not neglect Brooke’s needs.  What most likely occurred is Brooke at first did not mentally process Gary’s negative traits and then minimized his faults throughout the years, as partners tend to do with loved ones.  Gary loves himself so much that he also minimizes his faults.  However, Gary minimizes his fault as a selfish partner in relationships to such an extent that it takes an extremely sincere and honest speech from his best friend Johnny (Jon Favreau) for Gary to recognize his selfish perspective.  This self-awareness was necessary for Gary because as Knapp and Vangelisti said, “our perception of our self and the effect that that acknowledgment has on an individual changes as he or she systematically moves in, out, and around the various stages of relationships” and therefore it must also change the individual as they move through relationships.

Based on the book by Nicholas Sparks, the 2004 film, The Notebook, is an example of a relationship as a living organism; demanding mental, emotional and physical effort from each person to last.  Again, the story begins with an atypical introduction of the relationship however Allie (Rachel McAdams) and Noah (Ryan Gosling) have more differences than similarities.  They are from different social classes, have different perspectives on education and must deal with drastically different realities.  The most popular scene in the film is the reunion of Noah and Allie.  After spending a day on the lake feeding the ducks, and being drenched by an unexpected downpour of rain, Allie asks Noah why he did not put in the physical effort to continue the relationship, for her the emotional connection and mental interest had not ended.  Noah reveals his physical effort of writing a letter each day of the year for a year; his emotional connection and mental interest had not ended either, and he was still interested.  “It still isn’t over,” said Noah.  Then in a later following scene Noah again proclaims his mental and emotional dedication to Allie, he wants to embrace their differences and is up to the never ending task of getting to know her.  Later, in the elderly assisted living center, Noah continues his relationship sustaining efforts on a daily basis in hopes that Allie might mentally rejoin him in the relationship, she has developed Alzheimer.  Their three fold connection lasts for as long as the two are alive, as they die holding hands.  

Lastly mentioned in this analysis are the principles, theories and analyses used in conjunction to the many faces of attraction.  The late 90’s film Hope Floats is a great example of the Pollyanna Principle (Matlin and Stang); the principle that most people tend to describe themselves as optimists or rate themselves as “better than the average person.”[3] This story features a couple who meets in a very typical environment, high school, but end in the relationship in an atypical manner, on national television.  The first illustration of the Pollyanna Principle is seen in various scenes through-out the film, such as, when Birdee (Sandra Bullock) and Bernice (Mae Whitman) drive into Smithville and they speak of Birdee being the crowned “Queen of Corn” during the town’s festival. Bernice actually mistakenly says the “cream of corn” which I found to be a very interesting similarity to the phrase “cream of the crop.” This insinuates that Birdee may have thought she was better than the average person.  Birdee says to Bernice, “Your momma knew what it meant to shine;” implying that she held herself in high regard.  

Secondly, the Pollyanna Principle says people tend to expect more pleasant events to occur more likely than unpleasant events and more than often report, with passage of time, events are remembered as more and more pleasant.[4] There are a few clever, easy to miss lines in the scene where Birdee goes to an employment agency to get a job.  Dot, known as “polka dot” during high school says, “We didn’t exactly eat at the same lunch table,” or “nobody has called me that in a longtime,” and “was I really that terrible before.”  These distinctive conversation markers are obvious indications that the harmless high school teasing was much less pleasant than Birdee remembered.  Dot also says, “He [Bill, Birdee’s husband] always was a ladies man,” also indicating Birdee had turned a blind eye to Bill’s cheating as early as in high school. However, in the end of the scene Birdee humbles herself before Dot and honestly admits she was unaware of how hurtful she had been in the past, but she would really like to be employed yet still keep her dignity, she is asking for a pleasant outcome out of this unpleasant event.

The third illustration of the Pollyanna Principle is, usually people tend to overvalue the importance of pleasant events and to undervalue the importance of unpleasant events.[5] An example of this is the attic scene between Birdee and her mother, played by Gena Rowlands, where Birdee says, “Besides how could we have trouble, Prom Queen and Quarterback, the pride of Smithville…”  Birdee really plays up how important she was in her younger years, playing up the more pleasant part of her past.  Then she says, “At cocktail parties the women Bill worked with would never look at me.  There was always somebody better to talk to,” as she tells her mother her experiences after realizing Bill was cheating.  However, there is also an example of the reverse of this trait; Birdee has overvalued the unpleasant events of her life.  Birdee says to her mother, “I had to be pleasing mamma with the town joke as a mother.  I had to learn to be pleasing.”  Although her mother may have been an embarrassment in the past, I think over time she may have come to think of that experience to be worse than it truly was. 

Whether the initial interaction happens in a typical manner between typical people, like the Prom Queen and the quarterback similar to the characters Birdee and Bill in Hope Floats, a boy doing a stupid and crazy stunt to get a girl’s attention, like Noah climbing the Ferris wheel to get Allie to agree to a date in The Notebook or atypical people who meet in an atypical manner like the characters Brooke and Gary in The Break-Up.  The story of how relationship partners get together has always been a subject I wanted to explore.   I do not consider myself very “styled” in the manner of beginning and maintaining a healthy romantic relationship, but similar to the characters in the films discussed in this analysis I also had to acknowledge and then analyze my own perspective, identify my social goals and learn to communicate in a manner that can be received positively by a relationship partner.  It is all a part of the growing process of life.
 


Bibliography

Encarta Dictionary: English. (n.d.). Perception (noun). North America: Encarta.
Knapp, M. L. (1984). Interpersonal Communication and Human Relationships. Austin: Pearson.




[1] (Encarta Dictionary: English)
[2] (Encarta Dictionary: English)
[3] (Knapp, 1984)…pg. 153
[4] (Knapp, 1984)…pg. 153
[5] (Knapp, 1984) …pg.153

The identity struggle of the African American Female: My Life as an “Oreo”



For a child the imagination can be the best way to try on a new life.  A child can be an astronaut, a cowboy, the next action hero of a major blockbuster movie.  A child could even use their own imagination to be of a different race.  However, one must question the mental health of a child who would aspire to drastically change such an identifying detail as the color of their skin.  The evidence presented in this academic report will explain many facets of living life as a thoroughly educated, proper speaking, African-American female with stereotypically white mannerisms, speech patterns, and other personality characteristic traits.  In other words, this is my academic discussion of my early attempts to assimilate into a dominate culture to only to later accept myself for who I truly am, a lady of distinction who just happens to have brown skin.
 
Before I begin the retelling the details and influences that lead to me using my imagination to select an alternative race I must first discuss assimilation and childhood fears.  Since the early 90’s, the broadcast and commercial media has strongly campaigned for individual freedom and acceptance.  Television commercials advertise catchy slogans such as, the Army’s insistence for people to “be all that you can be,” the United Negro Funds warnings that “a mind is a terrible thing to waste” or Burger King’s relaxed policy that allows every individual specifically customize their meals reminds members of society we can “have it your way.”  However, most often a child does not really have a strong enough grip onto reality to determine what suits their own personal preferences.  Many grown adults are so fearful of the unknown to such a point that people have been accidentally killed due to inappropriate actions.  Therefore, the idea of acting like, speaking like and inherently taking on the mannerisms and characteristics of a dominating culture could very easily be seen as a method to not only survive, but to thrive.
One day in second grade, the teacher asked the class if each of us were granted a wish what would be our wish and then each student in the class said what their wish.  I had just moved to Chicago from the sunny beach town of Redondo Beach, California, a predominantly white school and believed somewhere some child might secretly share my feelings of loneliness or have a deep desire to become something else.  I really felt that my life did not mirror the images of life that I was seeing on television.  The thought behind the wish was that the wrong things that I had already experienced would not have happen to me if I was white.  White children have both a mother and a father, I had neither.  White children have dogs as pets, I had a rabbit.  In my mind, my life could be or would be perfect…all I had to be was white.  So if we are just using our imagination to the furthest extent then I would like to be white; and that is what I announced to Mrs. Nicolas’ second grade.  Surely if Geppetto could wish upon a star and get a son from a puppet then I can become a Caucasian.
Unfortunately, my wish to simply become a white person did not stop after my embarrassing proclamation.  Children can be cruel, but in their innocence children are more often curious than just mean.  So through-out the years, as the other kids would ask me why I talked white, acted white, and wished to be white it was not always with a malicious attitude.  The other children had only lived in one neighborhood their entire lives.  The adults and children in this small suburb all spoke the same way, thought mostly the same and basically lived the same lifestyle.  It was not always with malice intention that the other kids began asking me why I talked white. 
Because my formative speaking years were spent in California I had no idea that I had already previously adapted to my prior environment and had taken on the characteristics of an upper class, “valley” white girl.  Around the age of nine I told my aunt that I was not sure if I was going to be black when I grew up; and I was sincere.  To me the cost and rewards associated with being black were not attractive enough to persuade me to continue my association with “being black.”  My aunt is an extremely tolerant woman, especially of the impossible childish fantasies; she asked that I think seriously about this change and to keep her update on my final decision. 
As I grew into an adult I, like many other African-American females, began participating in the activities to reaffirm my assimilation into mainstream society’s idea of pretty.  I insisted on having a relaxer, a chemical process using sodium hydroxide and guanidine hydroxide, used in my hair.  This would make the hair straight (at the root) and flowing.  Reverend Al Sharpton called the process of “getting a relaxer” “combing our [black women and men] oppression and exploitation into our hair.”  There were times, in my twenties, when I would see my own skin and would be momentarily puzzled by my brown skin.  Mentally, I had become white, but then similar to the growth of mainstream trends of popular culture, something wonderful happened and I evolved.
From my observations, it seems “being black” has actually been incredibly trendy, hip and cool although it was also looked down upon by the members of the ruling elite and government(s).  For example, in the 70’s many African Americans gained a celebrity status by playing jive talking, only mildly emotional instruments of justice.  The character Shaft went many places in his films and no matter what type of crowd was around he was identified as a strong, dignified and educated black man.  He was a new and exciting entity the world, mainstream society, had imagined could never happen.  In the same regards, I have heard many remarks regarding very specific characteristics and mannerisms that I have begun to wonder if others may consider me a sight to behold.  One day during my internship, my internship coordinator said that I was very articulate and spoke very well, but that that must be a result of my theater training.  Although I had previously mentioned to him that I spent time in the world of theater I neglect to leave out the minor detail that my time was mostly spent backstage.   
Racism in contemporary America has changed; it is in a very subtle fashion.  There still seems to be this “understood” mental conception of Black people and that has tainted the mind of so many people.  The fact of the matter is actions like these are hard to dismiss.  One day while standing in line at a grocery store a Caucasian woman was obviously in a hurry, and she literally looked at me turned her nose up and then pushed her in front of me in the check- out line.  I said to her, “Oh were you trying to get out of the store?”   She ignored me as if I was not talking to her.  I said, “Excuse me.  You are in my way, I am checking out.”  She turned and looked at me like I smelled like day old fish.  She never opened her mouth.  Although the check- out girl was Caucasian as well because she witnessed the entire event she would not ring the lady’s items up.  She started to ring up my items behind this woman’s items.  The check- out girl said to her,” Ma’am you have to wait in line like everyone else!”  The store manager came over and took the woman to another register and had her items checked out.  Then she called me a Nigger.  I laughed in her face and said, “And yet you just portrayed a nigger perfectly.”  It was nice that the clerk was not willing to discriminate against me and treated us all the same.   But to say that that is common is simply not true.  I do not believe there is an African American in the United States under the age of forty who cannot tell you numerous stories of incidences that happened directly to them not just stories to pass on from someone else.
When the mindset of a person is such that they think, they believe, it is their understanding that they are better than you simply because your skin is not the same as theirs.  How do you challenge such a mind?  It is ignorance to look at another person and assess their life’s worth based on the criteria of skin color, or no skin color.  We were always taught that education is the foundation for intelligence and that your ability to learn is the true measure of intelligence.  If you cannot learn you have a much greater challenge to learn.  Education was stressed in our home we have descendants who died for the right to be educated.  Our family built a school, built a bus, and picked up the neighbors children took them to school and educated them.  Many of our older relatives were school teachers, Principal’s, and Superintendents of entire school districts.   My relatives understood, early in the 1920’s and 1930’s, that education was a way to elevate the sub standard of living for most Black American’s.  So they decided to foot the whole bill to educate young black children in their home state of Mississippi.  That is true dedication and commitment.  This is the behavior that can destroy disenfranchisement.
More recently, within this new millennium, the global community has begun to play a huge effect on its self.  As members of the global community do things, such as riots, protests, and so on that influences other members of the global community to take action and make a change in their location.  Strong, charismatic, beautiful, dark women have begun almost out shinning the stereotypical Caucasian looking females on almost every socioeconomic level.  The days when a white person in the South could walk in front of a black person standing at a deli counter and expect to be served have become few and far between within the past few decades, although those things do still happen.
Though I may be graduating from college with a degree in Communications I am not a scholar educated in the way, nor have I conducted an in-depth study on, the assessment of others.  The opinions, statements and generalizations I pose are based upon my own personal experiences and observations.  But from what I have seen, if one was to compare the sense (level) of camaraderie in ghettos of America versus the ghettos of India, I would say India outranks America ten to one.  When described by my white friends I have been consistently told I am intimidating, but people of any other color, creed or nation embrace me and instantly think I am sweet and gentle.  I just happen to be tall, not just happen to be black.  Hopefully one day mainstream society will honestly see me as a person who happens to be black; I guess I should be happy that in today’s society I am, first and foremost, viewed as a number. 

Saturday, September 1, 2012

Fledgling Nonprofit Workers Love Their Jobs but Bear Financial Burdens

The newest generation of nonprofit employees strongly wants to remain in jobs that do good—even as many of the workers struggle to get by on low entry-level salaries and pay back their student loans, according to a new survey by The Chronicle of Philanthropy.

Eight out of 10 new workers want to continue working at a nonprofit, even though 40 percent say they are dissatisfied with their pay. And about 65 percent said they have college-loan debt.

The survey, which tracked more than 900 people who have worked at nonprofits for less than five years, was conducted with help from the Nonprofit Leadership Alliance and the Young Nonprofit Professionals Network.

In addition to showing the financial status of fledgling employees, the survey paints a picture of improving economic health for charities.

Nearly 40 percent of the recent employees surveyed said they had landed their new positions after a job search lasting three months or less.

Continue Reading...

How I Shaped My Own Internship Experience

If the adage for real estate is location, location, location then the adage for succeeding after college is experience, experience, experience; and the best way to gain that experience is through a successful internship.

I learned that long before preparing for the internship interview it’s the intern’s responsibility to choose the overall outcome of the internship experience.  Either the semesters during the internship will be fun and not as work-heavy or will be extremely work-heavy with very little fun.

However, what many applicants are not told before beginning the search for the perfect internship site is that you are choosing it just as much as the organization is choosing you.

Have you asked yourself how the internship will help to accomplish your after college goals?  What kind of resume building, transferable and tangible skills will you walk away with?  What kind of attitude does the staff have about their work environment?

Continue Reading...

Press Release: Providers and Public Informed about Accessing Healthcare at the Healthy Lives, Healthy Futures Symposium



Houston, Texas, September 1, 2012—Now that the Supreme Court has upheld the Affordable Care Act, what does that mean for YOU? 

The Healthy Lives, Healthy Futures Symposium will be held September 7th -10th to educate an estimated 1.1 million uninsured and under insured members of the Greater Houston area community and healthcare providers on accessing healthcare.  The purpose of the symposium is to simplify the Affordable Care Act and to inform people on what the law will pay for, will not pay for and any out-of-pocket costs to expect in 2014. The event is free to everyone.

The event for the general public will be held on Sunday, September 9th from 3:30- 6:30 pm.  A variety of healthcare experts will be available Sunday afternoon to answer questions on how to access healthcare. Featured speakers, Randall Wright, MD and Veronica D. Moore, will speak about the impact of the Act to American citizens and what to expect when going from “sick care to health care.”  

Continue Reading...

A Case Analysis of the Motivation Hygiene Theory

In organizational communication the belief is theory guides behavior; and in this paper the Motivational-Hygiene theory will be applied to my life and work experiences.  To begin, the motivational-hygiene theory is commonly referred to as the “two-factor theory” because the theory regards both job satisfaction and dissatisfaction.  Shockley-Zalabak said the Motivation-Hygiene Theory emphasizes the influence of both internal and external factors in explaining human behavior.

Continue Reading...

The Relationship Between Language and Culture and Effective Communication

It is human nature for people to be symbol makers, users and abusers. The symbols created are words. These words can be complex, powerful and become vital to a person’s attitude or understanding of observed behavior, cultural thoughts and personal survival. Because of the incredible effect words have people are influenced to select or avoid certain words to effectively use persuasive and interpersonal communication. This essay will discuss the relationship between language and culture, while drawing the idea “language shapes thought” and behavior. The essay will also examine the effect communication has on the overall effect on one’s ability to persuade others using persuasion and interpersonal communication.

Why do communication theorists go to such great lengths to study the nature of communication? Communication happens through a series of comments and actions called interactions. It is within those interactions where the dynamics of the communication process can be found. Because, language is the only means of articulating thought people use it to express their feelings, to create and diminish interpersonal relationships and to divulge information. We create and share that information to reach a mutual understanding, about ourselves and others. What a person says or does, or is seen doing, influences the opinions, thoughts and the perception others will have about that them, either positively or negatively. My thoughts or experiences define my reality.

Continue Reading...